The pandas true thumb is committed to another role, too specialized for a different function to become an opposable, manipulating digit. For gould the pandas thumb is proof of a path that a sensible god would never tread, but that a natural process, constrained by history, follows. Gould one of suboptimalitys most vocal supporters presented what he believed to be perhaps the finest known example of nondesign ever to be found in naturethe pandas thumb. The panda s thumb provides an elegant zoological counterpart to darwins orchids. On the various contrivances by which british and foreign orchids are fertilized by. Excerpted from the pandas thumb out of the pandas thumb.
The pandas thumb even has a theme, of sorts, described by gould as a club sandwich of topics on biology and history. The giant pandas throat has a special coating it, so that they wont get splinters from the bamboo they eat. The book is kickstarted by goulds musings on the work of darwin, and in particular his observations of the unusual features of orchids. Reissued in a larger format, with a handsome new cover, the pandas thumb will introduce a new generation of readers to this unique writer, who has taken the art of the scientific essay to new heights. A little pandas in a park would you like to join it and play hide and seek. The book is arranged in eight sections, but there is a single. Giant pandas and the distantly related red pandas may have independently evolved an extra digit a false thumb through changes to the. Furthermore, the panda thumb is the sixth finger on its hand. Tracing the origin of the pandas thumb springerlink. It is the second volume culled from his 27year monthly column this view of life in natural history magazine. The pandas thumb from the pendulum to the lynx and the. The point of that essay and the next twoon turtle migration and animal luresis that nature is a tinkerer, making the most of whats available in the course of. The sesamoid bone of the giant panda, used similarly to a human thumb, cited as evidence of evolution and the main feature of an essay by stephen jay gould. Inthe late and highlyregarded evolutionary biologist stephen jay gould celebrated the concept of contingency in evolution with the development of the giant pandas false thumb.
Welcome to christian forums, a forum to discuss christianity in a friendly surrounding. Many famous evolutionists like stephen jay gould have popularized an argument that the pandas thumb is poorly designed and thereby could not have been designed. We investigate the relative development of the carnivoran radial sesamoids to untangle the evolution of this iconic structure. Apologetics press evolutions new argumentsuboptimality. The insect must then back out through the only available exit a path that. The 1992 edition even goes over some clarifications which have come into light in. The book s best, most honest moments come in the concluding chapter, in which meyer travels to see. If the giant panda ailuropoda melanoleuca and the red panda ailurus fulgens are not closely related, their sharing of this adaptation implies a remarkable convergence. Uniquely among ursine species, the panda eats bamboo, first stripping the leaves by rolling each bamboo stalk between its thumb and fingers. More reflections in natural history, a 1980 book by stephen jay gould featuring an essay on the pandas thumb. The pandas thumb is an overall interesting book dealing with the curiosities of evolution through a compendium of articles written by gould mostly in the 70s for.
The pandas true thumb is committed to another role, too specialized for a different. In his treatise on british and foreign orchids, darwin outlined an unusual arrangement of petals in the orchid, suggesting that they have been designed to. The riddle of the pandas thumb one of the classic stories used to illustrate evolution is even more remarkable than scientists had. More reflections in natural history is a collection of 31 essays by the harvard university paleontologist stephen jay gould. The pandas thumb will introduce a new generation of readers to this unique writer, who has taken the art. Watch a panda eat, and youll notice the thumblike appendage that helps it hold onto bamboo stalks. Its full of cute drawings of pishu and his mother and the writing is so sweet. The pandas thumb follows on the heels of his equally readable ever since darwin 1977, a collection drawn from the same journal. Recurring themes of the essays are evolution and its teaching, science biography, probabilities and common sense. It will come as no surprise to readers of the pandas thumb, but creationists have inadvertently discovered the modern theory of evolution. Gould today i recommend a different kind of book, a series of essays about biology and evolution targeted to all kinds of public.
See more ideas about panda, books and childrens books. Not only is it not a true thumb, but it cant move much. In the fall of my freshman year of college, i read an essay by stephen jay gould called the pandas thumb drawn, i think, from a book by the. Gould then applies the same premises to the pandas thumb. The books isnt new 1980 i think and some of the hypotheses have been discarded already. The pandas thumb is not a true finger, but the elongation of a wrist bone which, along with appropriated muscle tissue, allows the panda to hold its beloved bamboo while eating. If you watched the hand of a baby panda grow, you would see that the thumb develops from a wrist bone. Eldridge and i refer to this scheme as the model of punctuated equilibria. These awkward contrivances retain evidence of natural history and provide essential evidence against creation. It is normal for mammals to have sesamoid bones in the hand. Immediately download the the pandas thumb book summary, chapterbychapter analysis, book notes, essays, quotes, character descriptions, lesson plans, and more everything you need for studying or teaching the pandas thumb book. The pandas thumb is an overall interesting book dealing with the curiosities of evolution through a compendium of articles written by gould mostly in the 70s for nature magazine.
Our textbooks like to illustrate evolution with examples of optimal designnearly perfect mimicry of a dead leaf by a butterfly or of a poisonous species by a tasty relative. So the panda must use parts on hand and settle for an enlarged wrist. A less explicit theme of the book is error and imperfection and their role in science, not just as an unavoidable sideeffect of human enterprise but also as its essential driving force. The title essay presents the paradox that poor design is a better argument for evolution than good design, as illustrated by the a. It is primarily a bony support for the pad above it, a support the pandas true thumb and fingers can squeeze against to hold bamboo endo et al 1996. In fact, each of darwins books played its part in the grand and coherent. Figure adapted by permission from macmillan publishers ltd.
In the pandas both giant and red, this false thumb is known to perform a grasping role during bamboo feeding in both the red and giant pandas. An essay in my previous book, ever since darwin, told the tale of lampsilis, a. Wallace 47 5 darwins middle road 59 6 death before birth, or a mites nunc dimillis 69 7 shades of lamarck 76 8 caring groups and selfish genes 85. Wilson inscribed a motto from pliny, the great natural historian who died in his boots when he sailed across the bay of naples to study the eruption of mt. Nature, role of the giant pandas pseudothumb, nature, vol. His best known books are ever since darwin 1977, the pandas thumb 1980, the mismeasure of man 1981, and the.
The panda thumb is just one bone sticking out of the side of the hand. Is the pandas thumb a clumsy adaptation that refutes. The pandas thumb, entitled from one of these essays, is not quite as witty as his later works are, but his personable style and conversational approach make the book very readable. The panda s true thumb is committed to another role, too specialized for a different function to become an opposable, manipulating digit. More reflections in natural history stephen jay gould with a touch of humor, geology, evolutionary theory, biology, cartoon characters and even some references to baseball, the pandas thumb definitely makes excellent reading for people with all types of interests. Nick matzke, a scientist who blogs at pandas thumb.
Down to his theory of mongolism, and its racist residue. The pandas thumb more reflections in natural history prologue on the title page of his classic book, the cell in development and inheritance, e. Thus, the fossil record is a faithful rendering of what evolutionary theory predicts, not a pitiful vestige of a once bountiful tale. An original locomotor role has been inferred for ailurids, but this remains to be ascertained for ursids. Darwins orchid book is filled with similar illustrations of unique adaptations. After providing an exhaustive explanation of how the panda has 5 other digits in each hand, which function quite. Perhaps the greatest problem that he darwin had to tackle was the means by which adaptive characteristics were passed on from generation to generation, for the principles of genetics were still to be discovered at the time of darwins death.
In this essay, the author describes the anatomy and origin of the pandas thumb, which is not really a thumb at all, as an illustration of how imperfections in design can sometimes offer the best. More reflections in natural history 1980 is a collection of 31 essays by the harvard university paleontologist stephen jay gould. He published over twenty books, received the national book and national book critics circle awards, and a macarthur fellowship. The book s title essay discusses the evolutionary paradox posed by the panda s thumb. One of the more famous proponents of this view was arthur koestler, who had recently published a book that included this argument.
Panda and dysteleological arguments of stephen jay gould. It would have to have been formed out of parts that were available. You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with christians all over the world. The ancestral bears first digit the real thumb was not available due to its earlier specialization for walking. The false thumb of pandas is a carpal bone, the radial sesamoid, which has been enlarged and functions as an opposable thumb. More reflections in natural history by stephen jay gould, w. Pandas have 5 clawed fingers, and then an extra bone scientists call the pandas thumb that pandas use to grasp the bamboo while eating. The pandas thumb comes equipped not only with a bone to give it strength but. The pandas thumb provides an elegant zoological counterpart to darwins orchids. Nick matzke, a scientist who blogs at pandas thumb, makes a.
733 597 1233 567 1562 1332 722 1330 495 651 1125 626 433 1549 398 11 1221 547 871 196 694 1066 456 663 1512 1365 1069 1232 1008 803 811 1100 1022 1221 1486 617 1411 1249 630